Cyberjutsu: Cybersecurity for the Modern Ninja by Ben McCarty proposes a unique approach to cybersecurity: think like a ninja. Drawing on his background in cyber warfare and extensive research into declassified ninja scrolls, McCarty argues that these ancient warriors' centuries-old tactics and mindset offer surprisingly relevant lessons for defending against modern cyber threats.
The book is not about becoming a literal ninja but rather about adopting their strategic thinking and adapting their methods for the digital age.
Core Argument: Why Ninjas?
McCarty argues that traditional cybersecurity, which is often focused on reacting to the latest threats, would benefit from a more proactive and strategic approach. He sees ninjas, masters of information warfare in their time, embodying this proactive mindset. The ninja scrolls, far from being just about martial arts, reveal a deep understanding of:
Information Gathering and Reconnaissance: Ninjas excelled at mapping their targets, understanding their defenses, and identifying vulnerabilities.
Exploiting Human Weaknesses: Ninjas were masters of social engineering, using deception, manipulation, and the element of surprise to their advantage.
Operating Undetected: Stealth and leaving no trace were crucial to the ninja's success, much like modern cyber adversaries.
Adaptability and Resourcefulness: Ninjas were adept at using whatever tools and techniques were available to achieve their goals.
By understanding how ninjas operated, McCarty believes we can better anticipate and defend against the tactics of today's cyber adversaries, who often employ similar strategies in the digital realm.
Key Concepts and Recommendations:
The book explores a wide range of ninja techniques and how they translate into practical cybersecurity practices. Here are some of the key takeaways:
Network Mapping: Just as ninjas meticulously mapped castles and their surroundings, organizations need to have a thorough understanding of their own networks, including devices, data flows, and potential vulnerabilities. This includes going beyond automated scans and using diverse sources like PCAP analysis and configuration reviews to create detailed network maps (12).
Guarding and Human Controls: Traditional approaches often overlook the importance of "guarding," which McCarty defines as incorporating human vigilance and intervention into security practices (345). This is particularly important for vulnerabilities that are difficult to patch technically, requiring instead procedural controls, employee training, and a culture of awareness.
Xenophobic Security: Modern systems prioritize connectivity and interoperability, but this can make it easier for attackers to blend in. McCarty proposes "xenophobic security," creating unique internal characteristics within your systems that deviate from standard configurations (678). This makes it harder for unauthorized devices or users to operate undetected.
Advanced Authentication: The book draws on historical examples of challenge-response authentication to advocate for stronger authentication methods that go beyond simple passwords (910). This includes multi-factor authentication, dynamic challenges, and out-of-band verification techniques to thwart impersonation attempts.
Time Confidentiality: McCarty introduces the concept of "time confidentiality," limiting an adversary's access to accurate time information as a security measure (1112). This can disrupt attacks that rely on precise timing, force attackers to expose themselves by seeking time data, and introduce uncertainty into their operations.
Tool Awareness and "Living Off the Land": Recognizing that any tool can be weaponized, Cyberjutsu stresses the importance of careful tool management and monitoring (131415). Organizations should adhere to the principle of least functionality, regularly audit tool usage, and be vigilant for signs of tools being used for malicious purposes ("living off the land").
Sensor Strategies and Sensory Awareness: The book emphasizes the importance of strategically placed sensors for effective threat detection, focusing on likely attack paths rather than relying solely on dispersed sensors (1516). McCarty also suggests learning from ninjas' sensory awareness, hinting at the potential for new types of sensors based on smell, sight, and sound for enhanced threat detection in the digital world.
Network Bridging Countermeasures: Attackers often bypass security perimeters by building bridges – finding ways to connect across air gaps, network segments, or other boundaries (171819). Cyberjutsu recommends implementing countermeasures like Faraday cages, strong device authentication, and proactive threat modeling to identify and mitigate these bridging vulnerabilities.
Physical Security and Locks: While seemingly obvious, Cyberjutsu stresses that physical security remains crucial in the digital age, as any system accessible to an adversary is inherently vulnerable (202122). Organizations should upgrade physical locks, consider multi-stage locking systems, and be mindful of physical attack vectors.
Countering Social Engineering ("Moon on the Water"): The book analyzes "moon on the water," an ancient social engineering technique that lures targets outside their defenses by exploiting their trust or curiosity (2324). Modern countermeasures include employee training to recognize these tactics, limiting information disclosure, and restricting data access outside secure boundaries.
Proactive Insider Threat Mitigation: Instead of solely focusing on detecting insider threats after the fact, Cyberjutsu recommends a more proactive approach: fostering a work environment that doesn't create conditions for insider threats to thrive (252627). This includes addressing employee grievances, promoting transparency, and providing clear channels for resolving concerns.
Supply Chain Security ("Ghost on the Moon"): Cyberjutsu uses the "ghost on the moon" analogy to highlight the challenges of detecting and mitigating supply chain attacks (282930). Recommendations include rigorous supply chain risk management, vetting manufacturers, securing shipping and handling, conducting hardware inspections, and implementing tamper detection technologies.
Attribution Challenges and Deception ("Art of the Fireflies"): The book acknowledges the difficulty of attributing cyberattacks to specific sources, noting that attackers often employ deception techniques to mislead investigators ("art of the fireflies") (2313233). Cyberjutsu encourages developing robust attribution capabilities by analyzing attack patterns, correlating data, and understanding adversary motivations.
Live Capture and Threat Response: Cyberjutsu emphasizes the importance of "live capture" – gathering real-time data during an attack for analysis and response (343536). This requires investing in tools and capabilities to collect network traffic, system logs, and other relevant information while an attack is underway, rather than relying solely on post-incident forensics.
Destructive Attack Mitigation ("Fire Attacks"): The book compares modern destructive cyberattacks to historical "fire attacks" (373839). It recommends safeguards like network segmentation, data backups, and incident response plans that focus on containment and recovery.
Command and Control (C2) Disruption: Cyberjutsu stresses the need to disrupt adversary C2 channels – the covert communication methods attackers use to control compromised systems (404142). This includes implementing best practices like network segmentation, whitelisting, intrusion detection, and actively monitoring for and blocking suspicious communication patterns.
Call Sign Detection and Countermeasures: Drawing parallels with historical examples of secret communication signals, Cyberjutsu discusses the importance of detecting and understanding adversary "call signs" within network traffic (4344). This involves monitoring for unusual communication patterns, system behavior anomalies, and potential covert channels used by attackers to signal each other.
"Light, Noise, and Litter" Discipline and Threat Hunting: The book emphasizes the need for a keen eye for subtle indicators of compromise ("light, noise, and litter") (45464748). This includes analyzing network logs and system activity for patterns that, while insignificant in isolation, might point to malicious activity when considered together. This concept aligns closely with modern threat hunting practices.
Opportunistic Attack Awareness and Preparation: Cyberjutsu highlights how attackers exploit periods of confusion, distraction, or weakness to launch attacks (495051). It recommends developing strategies to maintain security vigilance during emergencies, outages, or other disruptive events that might weaken defenses.
Zero-Day Defense and Dynamic Strategies: The book acknowledges the challenges of defending against zero-day attacks (5253). It recommends a multi-faceted approach, including following best practices, adopting dynamic defense strategies, simplifying systems, and fostering a culture of security awareness and vigilance.
Talent Acquisition and Development: Cyberjutsu emphasizes the importance of hiring and developing talented cybersecurity professionals (5455). It encourages looking beyond traditional credentials and focusing on candidates with the mindset, problem-solving skills, and adaptability to thrive in a constantly evolving threat landscape.
Guardhouse Behavior and Security Culture: The book draws parallels between the complacency of historical guards and the potential for lax security practices in modern organizations (565758). Establishing a culture of vigilance, where all employees feel responsible for security, is paramount.
"Block Suspicious" Security Posture: Inspired by historical examples, Cyberjutsu explores a "block suspicious" security posture – denying access to unknown or untrusted entities by default rather than reacting only to known threats (596061). This requires careful whitelist management, robust authentication, and a security-aware culture that extends beyond the IT department.
Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) and Actionable Insights: Cyberjutsu underscores the vital role of CTI in understanding adversary tactics and developing effective defenses (626364). Importantly, it emphasizes the need for actionable intelligence – translating insights into concrete improvements, incident response plans, and proactive threat hunting initiatives.
Conclusion
Cyberjutsu doesn't offer a simple checklist of security measures. Instead, it provides a new framework for thinking about cybersecurity. By adopting the mindset of a ninja, learning from their methods, and understanding the enduring principles of information warfare, McCarty believes we can move beyond reactive security and build more resilient organizations in the digital age.
Share this post